Humans milk the periodic table turning a blind eye to its risks

The Bayan Obo mine in Inner Mongolia (China) contains a large amount of rare earth minerals. Source: REUTERS (2011).
The Bayan Obo mine in Inner Mongolia (China) contains a large amount of rare earth minerals. Source: REUTERS (2011).

For millions of years, nature has basically been getting by with just a few elements from the periodic table. Carbon, calcium, oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen, phosphorus, silicon, sulphur, magnesium and potassium are the building blocks of almost all life on our planet (tree trunks, leaves, hairs, teeth, etc.). However, to build the world of humans — cities, healthcare products, railways, aeroplanes and their engines, computers, smartphones — we need many more chemical elements. A recent article, published in the renowned journal Trends in Ecology and Evolution and written by researchers from CREAF, the Autonomous University of Barcelona (UAB) and the Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), warns that the range of chemical elements humans need (something scientifically known as the human elementome) is increasingly diverging from that which nature requires (the biological elementome).

Sustaining the human elementome will be more and more complicated and risky; it will need to be done in terms of environmental justice and, of course, with more rational use of Earth’s limited resources,”
JAUME TERRADAS, founder of CREAF, honorary professor at the UAB and one of the article’s three authors. ​

In 1900, approximately 80% of the elements humans used came from biomass (wood, plants, food, etc.). That figure had fallen to 32% by 2005, and is expected to stand at around just 20% in 2050. We are heading for a situation in which 80% of the elements we use are from non-biological sources. Non-biological elements are scarce or practically absent in living organisms, and rare in general; in many cases, their main reserves are located in just a handful of countries. They have to be obtained from geological sources, which entails extraction, trade between countries, and the development of efficient recycling technologies, while their scarcity and location create potential for social, economic, geopolitical and environmental conflicts. Thus, what might initially appear to be a purely scientific issue actually has much more far-reaching repercussions.

A few elements build almost all life on the planet, while humans need far more chemical elements. Image: CREAF.

Humanity, firmly bound to its expansive use of the periodic table

The study looks back at the history of humankind in relation to its use of the periodic table’s elements. According to the article, the human and biological elementomes started to diverge in the decade of the 1900s, a result of continuous growth in the use of non-biomass materials (fossil fuels, metallic/industrial materials, and building materials).

In 1900, 79% of all the materials humans used annually were biomass materials, compared to 32% in 2005 and the figure of 22% currently predicted for 2050. Elements used in construction, transport, industry and, more recently, new technologies, such as computation and photovoltaic devices and mobile phones, were added to the human elementome over the course of the 20th century. They include silicon, nickel, copper, chromium and gold, as well as others that are less common, such as samarium, ytterbium, yttrium and neodymium. In the last two decades, there has been an increase in the use of such scarce elements owing to the implementation and expansion of new technologies and clean energy sources.

Divergència creixent entre els elementomes humà total i biològic. Font: Penuelas, J., Sardans, J., & Terradas, J. (2022).

 

Growing divergence between the total human and biological elementomes. Font: Penuelas, J., Sardans, J., & Terradas, J. (2022).

Environmental, economic, social and geopolitical risks

The extraction of Earth’s chemical elements could be a limiting factor and lead to crises at every level

The article leaves no room for doubt: the extraction of Earth’s chemical elements could be a limiting factor and lead to crises at every level. Using more of the periodic table’s elements involves the extraction of more minerals, rising energy consumption and the associated CO2 emissions. Furthermore, the growing scarcity of the elements in question is a threat to their availability, especially where poorer countries are concerned, and makes maintaining production difficult even for wealthy countries, thus affecting economic development.

La mina

 

The mine “La Ganadería”, near San Martín de Turumbán (Venezuela), shows the signs of the extraction of the mercury. Source: Infoamazonia

Against that backdrop, there are also important and problematic geopolitical considerations. The natural reserves of some elements, including the rare-earth elements, are located in a limited number of countries (China, Vietnam, Brazil, the USA, Russia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo); China actually controls over 90% of the global supply and close to 40% of reserves. Their availability is therefore subject to fluctuations in supply and prices caused by opposed geopolitical interests, with the consequent danger of conflicts.

El canvi exponencial progressiu del elementoma humà total, definit com el número i les quantitats d'elements utilitzats biològica i no biològicament pels éssers humans. Aquest elementoma humà ha divergit cada vegada més del elementoma biològic que caracteritza els elements utilitzats biològicament. (A) Quantitats totals de biomassa i materials no biomásicos (Gt/a) utilitzats en el elementoma humà de 1990 a 2060. Material no biomásico = combustibles fòssils + materials metàl·lics/industrials + materials de construcció. (B) Quantitats totals de materials (Gt/any) utilitzats en el elementoma humà de 1990 a 2060 dividides per tipus de material (biomassa, combustibles fòssils, materials metàl·lics/industrials i materials de construcció).

 

The progressive exponential change in the total human elementome defined as the number and amounts of elements used biologically and nonbiologically by humans. This human elementome has increasingly diverged from the biological elementome that characterizes the elements used biologically.

Out with programmed obsolescence, in with recycling and recovery

The authors stress the need to put an end to programmed obsolescence (the policy of planning or designing a product to have an artificially limited useful life), as well as to develop new technologies that contribute to more profitable use of scarce elements and allow for their widespread, efficient recycling and reuse. At present, there are few, if any, alternatives to many such elements, and their recycling rates are low because they are used in small amounts in combination with other materials in a broad range of products. Current recovery techniques have poor efficiency levels and entail a high risk of pollution owing to the toxicity of rare-earth elements.

Sistema de reciclatge de neodimi, que pot fondre's per a fabricar nous imants. Font: Less Common Metals.
Neodymium recycling system, which can be used to make new magnets. Source: Less Common Metals.

The article mentions different technologies that could be used for the recovery of scarce elements. One is bioleaching, the extraction of metals from their ores through the use of living organisms, such as bacteria, which can accumulate rare-earth elements if they come into contact with industrial waste. To avoid pollution, meanwhile, scientists are studying biosorption, a physiochemical process that occurs naturally in certain organisms and enables them to filter pollutants, such as heavy metals in waste water. Other possibilities include cryomilling, in which recovery takes place through electrochemical deposition; the use of different carbon-based nanomaterials as means of sorption to preconcentrate rare elements from waste water from dissolved waste; hydrometallurgy for the substantial recovery of rare-earth elements and heavy metals from apatite and different scraps; and pyrometallurgy or the extraction of supercritical fluids with CO2. In any case, developing new ways of producing and recycling such elements on a large scale is essential.

Article:

Penuelas, J., Sardans, J., & Terradas, J. (2022). Increasing divergence between human and biological elementomes. Trends in Ecology & Evolution.

Related articles

Basalt is an abundant, highly resilient rock resource already used in agriculture, to a lesser extent in forestry, but so far rarely used in natural and restoration ecosystems. Image: Thomas Hays, under a Creative commons license.
News @en
Adriana Clivillé

How crushed rocks can help capture CO₂

Rock dust could remove 2.5 gigatonnes of CO₂ from the atmosphere, of which almost 50% would be thanks to the response of the biosphere, according